ProperProse
Episode 02 · 10 min · Published

The hearing is not the answer.

The minute order is. Why "what the judge said" matters less than what the clerk wrote, and how to make sure the two match.

People walk out of hearings with a feeling. The feeling is usually wrong, in either direction. You felt steamrolled and the order is fine; you felt vindicated and the minute order quietly granted exactly two of the four things you asked for. The minute order is the document. It is what binds. Read it within twenty-four hours.

If the minute order is wrong — meaning, it materially diverges from what was actually said and signed onto in open court — the remedy is not to argue with the court reporter, who works for the court and not for you. The remedy is a noticed motion to correct, or, if the divergence is small enough to live with, a notice of clarification on the record at the next available hearing. Pick your battles.

The notice-of-ruling problem

If the court directs opposing counsel to give notice — which it usually does — opposing counsel will draft a notice of ruling. That document will arrive in your inbox within a few days. Read it next to the minute order. If they match, log it. If they do not match, that is a separate problem with its own clock: respond on the record before defense's version becomes the assumed version of events.

Episode 03 picks this up at the level of service.

ProperProse Premium

The full archive. Member-only deep-dive expansion packs. Monthly office hours. Direct access when you need a thinking partner.

Cancel anytime from your Stripe customer portal. See terms + privacy.